Trump & Bessent Versus Powell & The Bond Vigilantes

Trump's Gambit to Sideline the Fed and Tame the Bond Market

The Trump administration is executing a high-stakes strategy to neutralize the Federal Reserve's influence and control borrowing costs by flooding the market with short-term debt. This maneuver, aimed at sidelining both Fed Chair Jerome Powell and the "bond vigilantes," sets the stage for a dramatic confrontation between political ambition and market discipline, with the trajectory of interest rates and asset prices hanging in the balance.

Key Insights

Trump's Plan to Neuter the Fed: A High-Stakes Bet on T-Bills

According to Ed Yardeni's analysis, the Trump administration, with guidance from Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, has devised a plan to circumvent the Federal Reserve's monetary policy. The core of the strategy is to finance the upcoming $9 trillion of maturing government debt almost exclusively with short-term Treasury bills (T-bills) rather than longer-term notes and bonds. This effectively bypasses the segment of the market where bond vigilantes wield the most power, allowing the Treasury to fund itself without being immediately disciplined by rising long-term yields.

"Trump now I think sees that as a great, that puts the cards in his hands. He likes to play cards. And so the cards now is he doesn't really care about Powell anymore because what he'll do is all finance all of that $9 trillion in T bills."

This tactic is the first step in a two-part plan. The second involves replacing Powell as Fed Chair in February with a loyalist who will be expected to push the FOMC to lower the fed funds rate. Yardeni labels this strategy "Treasury Yield Curve Control" (YCC-T), a direct assertion of executive influence over borrowing costs. However, he warns that the plan's success is not guaranteed. A politically motivated rate cut could be rejected by the bond market, which might interpret the move as fiscally reckless, potentially causing long-term yields to rise even as the Fed cuts its policy rate—a scenario that has occurred in the past.

The Myth of the All-Powerful Bond Vigilante

While markets are fixated on the threat of bond vigilantes punishing US fiscal policy, Yardeni argues this risk is often exaggerated due to a misunderstanding of the debt composition. Although total US public debt is a staggering $27 trillion, the actual amount of outstanding long-term Treasury bonds—the primary instrument the vigilantes use for discipline—is only $5 trillion. The vast majority of the debt is in shorter-term bills and notes, which face consistently high demand.

"Treasury bonds are $5 trillion of that now. $5 trillion, a trillion here, a trillion there. It's big money, but it's $5 trillion... $5 trillion is pretty piddling when you think about it. So maybe we're all getting excited about $27 trillion... but a lot of that is bills and nobody's ever going to Wonder whether there's demand for bills and two to five year notes."

Yardeni suggests that in a global financial system with over $300 trillion in total debt, finding buyers for $5 trillion in US long bonds is not an insurmountable challenge. This context diminishes the immediate threat of a full-blown buyers' strike. While the vigilantes did get Trump's attention when the 10-year yield shot up to 4.5% following "Liberation Day" tariff announcements, their power may be more limited than headline debt figures suggest, giving the administration more room to maneuver with its T-bill strategy than many believe.

Economic Nirvana: Why the Fed is Paralyzed and Yardeni is "None and Done"

Yardeni describes the current US economy as being in a state of "nirvana," where the data supports keeping policy on hold. With the unemployment rate at a low 4.1% and inflation nearing the 2% target—he notes the Cleveland Fed's Nowcast for July CPI is just +0.07%—the Fed's dual mandate is effectively being met. He argues that if you exclude the lagging rent component, both headline and core CPI are already below 2%, suggesting the current fed funds rate is appropriately positioned.

This leads Yardeni to a "none and done" forecast, believing the Fed should not adjust interest rates for the foreseeable future. He fundamentally disagrees with the FOMC's stated bias toward cutting rates, viewing it as unnecessary given the economic strength. This creates a complex dynamic: the economic data calls for inaction, the Fed's own guidance signals an easing bias, and the White House is applying immense political pressure to cut. This policy uncertainty, rather than a clear economic signal, has become a primary driver of market volatility.

The AI-Driven "Melt-Up" Carries "Meltdown" Risk

The stock market's powerful recovery has the characteristics of a "melt-up," with the S&P 500's forward P/E multiple returning to a rich 21-22. This rally is fueled by intense optimism surrounding Artificial Intelligence. However, Yardeni raises a contrarian flag, warning that this boom carries the seeds of a future "meltdown." He is particularly concerned about a potential glut in data center capacity, spurred by a global building frenzy and aggressive tax incentives like the 100% depreciation allowance in the US.

"This may turn out to be a melt up, meltdown situation if and when we discover that AI is, is a, is a wonderful technology, but it's prone to hallucinations... that it's artificial but not intelligent."

As a regular user of AI tools, Yardeni questions the narrative of flawless, revolutionary productivity gains. He emphasizes that AI models are probabilistic, require constant human verification, and are not truly "intelligent." If the technology fails to deliver on its lofty promises or the massive investment in infrastructure leads to a capacity surplus, the AI-centric market leaders could face a severe correction. Investors are therefore caught between riding the powerful momentum of the melt-up and managing the growing risk of an eventual bust.

Insightful Quotes

On Trump's strategy to bypass the Fed: "Trump now I think sees that as a great, that puts the cards in his hands. He likes to play cards. And so the cards now is he doesn't really care about Powell anymore because what he'll do is all finance all of that $9 trillion in T bills." - Ed Yardeni

On the real power of bond vigilantes: "Treasury bonds are $5 trillion... $5 trillion is pretty piddling when you think about it... So maybe we're all getting excited about $27 trillion... but a lot of that is bills." - Ed Yardeni

On the risk embedded in the AI boom: "This may turn out to be a melt up, meltdown situation if and when we discover that AI is... artificial but not intelligent." - Ed Yardeni

Market Implications

The collision between Trump's political agenda and market forces creates a complex and uncertain investment landscape.

  • Fixed Income: The path for the 10-year Treasury yield is now a political football. Trump's T-bill strategy is designed to suppress long-term rates, but if the market loses confidence in US fiscal discipline, yields could spike regardless of Fed actions. Yardeni maintains a forecast for the 10-year yield to trade within a range of 4.25% to 4.75%, suggesting that for now, market forces and political pressure are in a tense equilibrium.

  • Equities: The market is in an earnings-driven melt-up, but at valuations that leave little room for error. The key is to distinguish between companies with tangible earnings growth and those running on pure AI narrative. While the momentum can continue, the "meltdown" risk is significant, particularly in sectors like data centers where over-investment is a growing concern. A focus on quality and reasonable valuations is critical.

  • US Dollar: Despite widespread bearishness and political jawboning aimed at weakening the currency, the US dollar may prove more resilient than expected. Yardeni's contrarian view is that the unparalleled depth and liquidity of US capital markets provide a structural support for the dollar that political rhetoric cannot easily dismantle. Fading the consensus bearish view on the dollar could present a strategic opportunity for investors.